Appeal Record
Home Site Map Profiles-Lawyers
Dyn. Chiro. Art. Ch. Journ. Art. A.G. Opinions Appeal Record Laws 1876-1923 Pre-1922 Proposed Laws Chiro. Bd. Filings Miscellaneous
 

ALPHABETICAL INDEX
(From Joint Appendix)
TO THE
TRIAL COURT RECORD FILED WITH APPELLATE COURT

NOTES:

1)   Several chiropractic organizations filed letters with the Supreme Court supporting
the Tain petition for review with that Court.  So too did several non-chiropractic persons and/or organizations.  Three of the letters from non-chiropractors may be reviewed on this site:

      a)  The Institute of Noetic Sciences (Marilyn Schlitz, Ph.D. - Director of Research):
      b)  Nature's Own Research Association (James L. Oschman, Ph.D.; and
      c)  Former President of Arizona Board of Homeopathic Examiners
           (Bruce H. Shelton, MD, MD(h), DiHOM)
 
2)  The plaintiffs named the California Acupuncture Board (CAB) as a defendant in their action and in their Fourth Cause of Action sought a judicial declaration that to allow MD's, DO's, podiatrists and dentists to use acupuncture needles but not chiropractors is invalid.  (Various grounds for this conclusion were raised and may be reviewed from the complaint itself.)  The trial court rejected the plaintiffs' position and the plaintiffs DID NOT include the CAB in their appeal.  However, certain documents filed by the CAB are included in the following record because the deputy attorney general representing the BCE specifically incorporated arguments (the included documents) made by the CAB into the arguments presented by the BCE.

3)  Link to the cited documents by clicking on the page number or text as indicated.  

Appeal - Procedural Documents

Document Title and Description (Alphabetized)                                                Page No.

Notice of Appeal                                                                                                      1
Notice of Intention to Proceed without Reporter's Transcript                                   4
Trial Court Judgment                                                                                                6

Pleading Documents

State Board of Chiropractic Examiner's (hereafter BCE) Answer to Plaintiff's
Second Amended Complaint (hereafter complaint)                                                   216
Plaintiff's Second Amended Complaint (Complaint & Ballot - load slowly.     
You may want to right click on link(s) and then use Target Save As to download
them to your computer and open them there.)
                                                            15
     Exhibit A      -  1922 Ballot Measure (Chiropractic Act)
     Exhibit B      -   BCE Rule 302
     Exhibit C-1   -  1948 Amendment to Chiropractic Act
     Exhibit C-2   -  1970 Amendment to Chiropractic Act
     Exhibit C-3   -  1976 Amendment to Chiropractic Act
     Exhibit C-4   -  1978 Amendment to Chiropractic Act

                                                           Demurrer Documents

Documents Submitted by the California Acupuncture Board (hereafter CAB)
(These documents were incorporated into BCE's arguments in Trial Court)
:

Acupuncture Board's Points and Authorities in Support of      
Demurrers to Plaintiffs' Complaint                                                                             122
CAB's Closing Points and Authorities in Support of Demurrers to
Plaintiffs' Complaint                                                                                                   205

Documents Submitted by the BCE:

BCE's Demurrers to Plaintiffs' Complaint                                                                   92
BCE's Points and Authorities in Support of Demurrers to Plaintiff's Complaint         96
BCE's Reply to Plaintiffs' Opposition to its Demurrers                                              193

Documents Submitted by Plaintiffs:

Plaintiffs' Points and Authorities in Opposition to CAB's General Demurrers          175
Plaintiffs' Points and Authorities in Opposition to BCE's General Demurrers           145


Judges Ruling Denying Demurrers:

"Denial" of BCE and CAB Demurrers and Requests for Judicial
Notice, and granting Pro Hac Vice application                                                         215

Motion for Summary Judgment/Adjudication Documents
(Except Requests for Judicial Notice)

Documents Submitted by the California Acupuncture Board (CAB)
(These documents were incorporated into BCE's arguments in Trial Court):

CAB's Points and Authorities in Support of Motion Summary
Judgment/Adjudication                                                                                              318

Documents Submitted by the BCE:

BCE's Notice of Motion for Summary Judgment/Adjudication and Separate
Statement of Undisputed Material Facts                                                                    240
BCE's Points and Authorities in Support of Motion for Summary J./Adjudication    254
BCE's Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary J./Adjudication       540
BCE's Response to Plaintiffs' Request for Judicial Notice                                        501
BCE's Response to Plaintiffs' Separate Statement of Disputed and
Undisputed Facts                                                                                                        533
Declaration of Jeanine Smith in Support of BCE's Motion for Summary J./
Adjudication                                                                                                              283

Documents Submitted by Plaintiffs:

Plaintiffs' Points and Authorities in Opposition to the CAB's Motion for
Summary J./Adjudication                                                                                          504
Plaintiffs' Points and Authorities in Opposition to the BCE's Motion for
Summary J./Adjudication                                                                                          360
Plaintiffs' Response to BCE's Separate Statement of  Disputed and
Undisputed Facts                                                                                                       351

Requests for Judicial Notice in Support and in Opposition to
Motions for Summary Judgment/Adjudication

BCE's Request for Judicial Notice in Support of Motion for
Summary J./Adjudication
                                                                                          288

     Exhibit B:  Certificate of Licensure of Lawrence Tain, D.C.                               294
     Exhibit C:  Certificate of Licensure of Robert F. Bitters, D.C.                            296
     Exhibit D:  Certificate of Licensure of Lori Prescott, D.C.                                  298
     Exhibit E:  Certificate of Licensure of Don N. Nielsen, D.C.                              300
     Exhibit F:  Certificate of Licensure of Stephanie Wattenberg, D.C.                       302
     Exhibit G:  Title 16, California Code of Regulation section 330, et seq.            304
     Exhibit H:  Title 16, California Code of Regulation section 340, et seq.            312

Plaintiffs' Request for Judicial Notice in Support of Opposition to BCE's
Motion for Summary J./Adjudication - Volume I (1 of 3)
                                         389

(Exhibits B, C, F and the various MPA's in Exhibit H - load slowly.  
You may want to right click on link(s) and then use Target Save As
to download them to your computer and open them there.)

     Exhibit A:  Declaration of David Prescott in Support of Admission of
                       Exhibits listed below                                                                           393
     Exhibit B:  "ENGROSSED STATEMENT ON APPEAL" in the case of
                       People v. Fowler (1938) 32 Cal.App.2d (Supp) 121                        397
     Exhibit C:  "PRE-TRIAL ORDER & JOINT PRE-TRIAL STATEMENT"
                       from the trial court record in the case of
                       Crees v. Bd. of Medical Examiners (1963) 213 Cal.App.2d 195     425
     Exhibit D:  "Medical Board of California - Affiliated Healing Art":
                       definitions of education and training for "medical assistants"             444
     Exhibit F:  1922 Ballot Initiative Measure 16, Chiropractic Act
                       (slightly enlarged for legibility purposes)                                           450
     Exhibit G:  Register 54, No. 10 - 5-8-54, Rule 302 (1954 version)                    460
     Exhibit H1913 Medical Practice Act (MPA - cropped to speed loading),
                       1907 MPA (with 1909 amendment thereto),
                       1901 Osteopathic Act, and the 1876 MPA                                         463

Miscellaneous Documents

Case Management Statement filed Jointly by the BCE and CAB                              345
Dismissal with Prejudice - as to only the Third Cause of Action to the
Plaintiffs' Complaint as to the Council on Chiropractic Education                             572
Stipulated Settlement between plaintiffs and defendant Council on
Chiropractic Education                                                                                             546
Stipulation RE Contents of Joint Appendix                                                               574